Should ESG be killed off or better integrated into business decision-making processes?
Death of ESG? Long Live Holistic Risk Management: A Risk Management Expert’s Perspective
For over a decade, Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) investing has dominated sustainable investing conversations. Proponents lauded its ability to integrate ethical considerations into investment decisions, while critics questioned its effectiveness and pointed out potential greenwashing. A more holistic approach to business decision is worth considering: Holistic Risk Management (HRM).
This article argues that while ESG has valuable elements, it falls short of a comprehensive risk management framework. We’ll explore the limitations of ESG and delve into the benefits of Holistic Risk Management. Through nine key differences, we’ll illustrate how HRM offers a more robust and future-proof approach to sustainable investing.
The Rise and Fall of ESG
ESG investing aimed to consider a company’s environmental impact (pollution, resource use), social responsibility (labour practices, diversity), and governance (transparency, board structure) alongside traditional financial metrics. This focus resonated with investors seeking alignment with their values and a potential hedge against future environmental and social risks.
However, ESG faced several challenges:
Lack of Standardisation: ESG ratings varied significantly between agencies, making comparisons difficult.
Data Transparency Issues: Companies often lacked consistent and verifiable ESG data, leading to accusations of greenwashing.
Focus on Short-Term Issues: ESG often prioritised easily measurable metrics over long-term, complex risks.
These limitations led some to question whether ESG truly delivered on its promise.
Enter Holistic Risk Management
Holistic Risk Management (HRM) offers a more comprehensive approach. It integrates ESG factors alongside a wider range of risks, both financial and non-financial. Here’s how HRM expands upon ESG:
By adopting HRM, companies gain several advantages:
Enhanced Resilience: A comprehensive understanding of risks helps companies prepare for a wider range of challenges.
Improved Decision-Making: Integrating risk considerations into strategic decision-making fosters better resource allocation and long-term sustainability. By proactively managing risks, companies can avoid costly pitfalls and seize opportunities that might arise from changing circumstances.
Competitive Advantage: Strong risk management practices build investor confidence. Companies that demonstrate a commitment to HRM become more attractive to investors seeking sustainable and resilient investment opportunities. This can lead to a lower cost of capital and increased access to funding.
ESG: A Stepping Stone, Not a Destination
ESG remains a valuable tool for focusing on environmental, social, and governance issues. It has undoubtedly played a role in raising awareness of these critical factors and pushing companies to improve their practices. However, its limited scope and focus on readily quantifiable metrics fail to capture the complete risk landscape.
HRM: The Future of Sustainable Investing
Holistic Risk Management offers a more holistic approach, enabling companies to build long-term resilience and navigate an increasingly complex world. Regulatory bodies and investors are increasingly acknowledging the limitations of ESG and recognizing the value of HRM. For example, the Financial Stability Board (FSB) has emphasized the importance of considering climate-related risks within risk management frameworks.
A Call to Action
The future of sustainable investing lies in embracing a holistic approach. Here’s what different stakeholders can do to move forward:
Investors: Encourage companies to move beyond ESG by prioritising HRM in your engagement strategies. Integrate questions about a company’s risk management framework and its approach to non-financial risks into your investment decision-making process.
Standard-Setting Bodies: Develop robust and standardised frameworks for HRM disclosure. This will allow investors to make informed comparisons between companies and hold them accountable for their risk management practices.
By working together, we can create a more sustainable and resilient investment landscape for the future. Holistic Risk Management offers a comprehensive approach that considers not just the financial bottom line, but also the environmental and social impacts of investment decisions. By embracing HRM, we can ensure a future where profitability and sustainability go hand-in-hand.
Get help to protect and grow your business with holistic risk management
Why the UK Cannot Complete Major Infrastructure Projects on Time and Within Budget
The UK has a long history of struggling to deliver major infrastructure projects on time and within budget. This has led to a number of high-profile delays and cost overruns, as well as a growing public frustration with the way in which infrastructure projects are managed.
There are a number of factors that contribute to the UK’s poor record on infrastructure delivery. These include:
A lack of long-term planning and strategic thinking. The UK government has often been accused of adopting a short-term approach to infrastructure planning, which has led to a lack of consistency and continuity.This has made it difficult to develop a long-term pipeline of projects that can be delivered efficiently.
A complex and fragmented procurement process. The UK’s procurement process is often complex and time-consuming,which can lead to delays and cost overruns. This is partly due to the fact that there is a lack of standardisation and consistency across different government departments and agencies.
A lack of expertise in managing large infrastructure projects. There is a shortage of skilled project managers in the UK, which can make it difficult to find the right people to lead and manage complex projects. This is compounded by the fact that many project managers in the UK are not properly trained or experienced.
A lack of political will to make tough decisions. The UK government has often been unwilling to make the tough decisions that are necessary to deliver major infrastructure projects on time and within budget. This is partly due to a fear of political backlash, but it is also due to a lack of understanding of the importance of infrastructure investment.
These factors have all contributed to a culture of risk aversion within the UK’s infrastructure industry. This has led to a focus on minimising risks rather than maximising value for money. As a result, projects are often over-engineered and over-specified, which leads to delays and cost overruns.
How to improve the UK’s record on infrastructure delivery
There are a number of things that the UK government can do to improve its record on infrastructure delivery. These include:
Develop a long-term infrastructure plan. The UK government needs to develop a long-term infrastructure plan that sets out the country’s infrastructure needs for the next 20 to 30 years. This plan should be based on a clear understanding of the country’s economic and social needs, and it should be regularly reviewed and updated.
Streamline the procurement process. The UK government needs to streamline the procurement process to make it more efficient and transparent.This could be done by standardising procurement procedures across different government departments and agencies, and by making more use of technology.
Invest in training and skills development. The UK government needs to invest in training and skills development to ensure that there is a sufficient supply of skilled project managers. This could be done by supporting professional development programs and by providing funding for apprenticeships and other training initiatives.
Make tough decisions. The UK government needs to be willing to make the tough decisions that are necessary to deliver major infrastructure projects on time and within budget. This includes making decisions about project scope, risks, and procurement.
Focus on value for money. The UK government needs to focus on value for money when delivering infrastructure projects. This means ensuring that projects are delivered to the highest possible standard, while also ensuring that they are delivered on time and within budget.
Improve project management practices. The UK government needs to improve project management practices across the public sector. This could be done by providing training and support to project managers, and by developing and implementing project management standards.
Increase investment in infrastructure. The UK government needs to increase investment in infrastructure. This will help to address the country’s infrastructure deficit and create jobs.
Publicly disclose project details. The UK government needs to publicly disclose all project details, including costs, risks, and timelines. This will help to improve transparency and accountability.
Appoint a dedicated infrastructure minister. The UK government needs to appoint a dedicated infrastructure minister who will be responsible for overseeing the delivery of all major infrastructure projects.
By taking these steps, the UK government can improve its record on infrastructure delivery and ensure that future projects are delivered on time and within budget.
In addition to the above, I would also like to add that the UK government needs to adopt a more collaborative approach to infrastructure delivery. This means working more closely with the private sector, as well as with local communities. By working together, the government and the private sector can share risks and expertise, and develop innovative solutions to infrastructure challenges.
The UK government also needs to be more open to using new technologies, such as modular construction and 3D printing. These technologies can help to reduce the time and cost of delivering infrastructure projects.
Find the best risk expert for your country or industry with BusinessRiskTV.com
Business Experts Network
ExpertsHub of risk management experts. Business experts network. Risk Experts Hub. Take more balanced risks to achieve more with risk experts to help you. Avoid taking risks blindly and letting risk events occur in the risk knowledge gap. Connect with risk management experts online.
Create greater business value with more confidence.
BusinessRiskTV
Our global experts can help you online and our local risk experts can come and visit you. Look to the future with our risk experts. Put in place the controls to mitigate threats. Seize new business development opportunities paying greatest return.
Join the discussion with our risk experts online for free
Assess your key risks and make better business decisions more often. Ask for help or share better business solutions. Connect in our business experts network to improve your business performance.
Subscribe to BusinessRiskTV for free alerts bulletins and risk reviews from risk experts to your inbox
Corporate risk management expert tips advice and support. Analysing all types of corporate risk. Are you a management expert wanting to develop your business. What must you know about corporate risks today? Our corporate risk management experts help you focus your resources on corporate risks that matter. Protect and grow your business faster with less uncertainty.
Our risk management specialists are industry business leaders country risk experts or highly experienced risk managers and consultants. Their training skills and experience will help you identify key threats and opportunities which could negatively or positively impact on your business objectives.
Take a more holistic risk management approach for all types of risks facing your business to be more successful in future
BusinessRiskTV
Risk events from any type of risk on its own or in combination can be fatal to an business strategy. Corporate risk management experts can be embedded in your decision making to support and advise on developing a new risk management strategy for greater certainty and success in business.
Integrating corporate risk management into strategic operational and project decision making will help you get the most out of your investment of time and money.
Being successful in business is about managing risks cost effectively not risk avoidance
Take controlled risks to achieve more for your business. Effective risk assessment and risk management will give you more confidence you are making the best decisions bearing in mind external and internal business risk factors.
Create more corporate value. Build stronger business resilience regardless of business environment to beat your competition with better corporate risk management.
Incorporate enterprise risk management practices into your business decision-making process
10 Fundamentals Of Corporate Risk Management Guide
In today’s dynamic business landscape, organisations face numerous challenges and uncertainties that can impact their success. To navigate these complex waters, companies need to develop robust risk management strategies. Effective risk management enables businesses to identify, assess, and mitigate potential risks, protecting their assets, reputation, and bottom line. In this comprehensive guide, BusinessRiskTV provides invaluable insights into corporate risk management, highlighting key principles, methodologies, and best practices to help organisations stay resilient and thrive in the face of uncertainty.
Understanding Risk Management To effectively manage risks, it is essential to have a clear understanding of what risk management entails. Risk management is a proactive process that involves identifying, assessing, prioritising, and mitigating potential threats and opportunities that can impact an organisationās objectives. By embracing risk management, businesses can make informed decisions, optimise opportunities, and protect themselves from potential harm.
The Importance of Risk Culture Risk management is not solely the responsibility of a dedicated department but should be embedded within an organisationās culture. Establishing a risk-aware culture ensures that risk management becomes an integral part of everyday operations. By fostering a culture that encourages open communication, accountability, and continuous learning, companies can create an environment where risks are identified, discussed, and managed effectively at all levels.
The Risk Management Process A structured risk management process is crucial for systematic and effective risk mitigation. This section outlines the key steps involved in the risk management process:
a. Risk Identification: Identify potential risks that could impact the organisationās objectives. This involves analysing internal and external factors, conducting risk assessments, and seeking input from various stakeholders.
b. Risk Assessment: Evaluate the likelihood and potential impact of identified risks. This step involves quantifying risks, considering their interdependencies, and prioritising them based on their significance.
c. Risk Mitigation: Develop strategies and action plans to manage and mitigate identified risks. This may involve implementing preventive measures, transferring risks through insurance, or creating contingency plans to minimise the potential impact.
d. Risk Monitoring and Review: Continuously monitor and review the effectiveness of risk management strategies. Regular evaluations help identify emerging risks, reassess existing risks, and ensure the implemented measures remain relevant.
Types of Risks in Corporate Environments Businesses face a wide range of risks across different aspects of their operations. Understanding these risks is essential for effective risk management. Here are some key types of risks commonly encountered in corporate environments:
a. Strategic Risks: Risks associated with the organisationās strategic decisions, such as market volatility, changing consumer preferences, or technological disruptions.
b. Operational Risks: Risks arising from internal processes, systems, or human errors, including supply chain disruptions, equipment failures, or cybersecurity breaches.
c. Financial Risks: Risks related to financial management, including market fluctuations, liquidity issues, credit risks, or non-compliance with regulatory requirements.
d. Compliance Risks: Risks associated with non-compliance with laws, regulations, or industry standards, potentially leading to legal consequences, reputational damage, or financial penalties.
e. Reputational Risks: Risks that can harm an organization’s reputation, such as negative publicity, customer dissatisfaction, or unethical behaviour.
f. Environmental and Social Risks: Risks associated with environmental sustainability, social responsibility, and stakeholder expectations. These risks can include climate change impacts, community relations, or labour issues.
Risk Assessment Techniques To effectively manage risks, organisations employ various techniques to assess and prioritise potential threats. Some commonly used risk assessment techniques include:
a. Qualitative Risk Assessment: Involves evaluating risks based on subjective criteria, such as likelihood and impact, using qualitative scales or matrices. This method provides a qualitative understanding of risks but does not involve precise numerical calculations.
b. Quantitative Risk Assessment: Utilises quantitative data and statistical analysis to assess risks. This involves assigning numerical values to likelihood and impact, calculating risk scores, and prioritising risks based on their quantitative measures. Techniques such as Monte Carlo simulations and sensitivity analysis can be employed for more accurate assessments.
c. Scenario Analysis: Involves developing hypothetical scenarios to evaluate risks and their potential impacts. By exploring different scenarios, organisations can assess the likelihood and consequences of specific events or situations and develop appropriate risk response strategies.
d. SWOT Analysis: A strategic planning tool that assesses an organisationās strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and threats. This analysis helps identify risks arising from internal factors (strengths and weaknesses) and external factors (opportunities and threats), allowing companies to develop targeted risk mitigation strategies.
e. Delphi Technique: A structured method that involves obtaining input from multiple experts or stakeholders anonymously. The experts provide their opinions on potential risks, and the responses are collated and analysed to identify areas of consensus and disagreement. This technique helps capture diverse perspectives and improve risk assessments.
Risk Mitigation Strategies Once risks are identified and assessed, organisations need to develop appropriate risk mitigation strategies. Here are some common strategies employed in corporate risk management:
a. Risk Avoidance: Involves eliminating activities or situations that pose significant risks. This strategy may include discontinuing certain products or services, exiting high-risk markets, or terminating partnerships with unreliable entities.
b. Risk Reduction: Focuses on minimizing the likelihood or impact of risks. This can be achieved through implementing control measures, improving operational processes, enhancing security systems, or implementing redundancy plans.
c. Risk Transfer: Involves transferring the financial burden of risks to external parties. This can be done through insurance policies, contracts, or outsourcing certain activities to specialised service providers who assume responsibility for specific risks.
d. Risk Acceptance: Sometimes, organizations may choose to accept certain risks if the cost of mitigation outweighs the potential impact. However, even in such cases, organisations need to closely monitor and manage accepted risks to minimise adverse outcomes.
e. Risk Diversification: Spreading risks across different markets, products, or business lines can help reduce the concentration of risks. Diversification provides a buffer against the impact of specific risks and ensures that the organisation is not overly exposed to a single threat.
f. Crisis Management Planning: Developing robust crisis management plans enables organizations to respond effectively to unforeseen events. This involves outlining clear roles and responsibilities, establishing communication protocols, and conducting regular drills to test the plan’s efficacy.
The Role of Technology in Risk Management Technology plays a vital role in modern risk management practices. Innovative tools and technologies enable organisations to enhance their risk management processes in several ways:
a. Data Analytics: Advanced data analytics techniques allow organisations to extract meaningful insights from vast amounts of data. By analyzing historical and real-time data, organizations can identify patterns, detect emerging risks, and make informed decisions.
b. Risk Monitoring and Early Warning Systems: Real-time monitoring systems powered by artificial intelligence and machine learning can identify potential risks and alert organizations to take timely action. These systems provide early warnings, enabling proactive risk management.
c. Cybersecurity Measures: With the increasing prevalence of cyber threats, robust cybersecurity measures are critical for protecting sensitive data and systems. Implementing firewalls, encryption techniques, and intrusion detection systems helps mitigate cybersecurity risks.
d. Automation and Robotics: Automation technologies streamline risk management processes, reducing human errors and improving efficiency. Robotic process automation (RPA) can handle repetitive tasks, data entry, and report generation, freeing up valuable human resources for more strategic risk management activities.
e. Cloud Computing: Cloud-based solutions provide organisations with secure storage, easy access to data, and enhanced collaboration capabilities. Cloud computing enables real-time data sharing, facilitates remote work, and improves business continuity in the event of a crisis.
f. Predictive Analytics: Predictive modeling techniques leverage historical data and algorithms to forecast future risks and trends. By analysing past patterns and behaviours, organisations can proactively identify potential risks and take preventive measures.
Integrated Risk Management Integrated risk management (IRM) is an approach that combines all aspects of risk management into a unified framework. IRM breaks down silos and fosters collaboration among different risk management functions within an organization. By integrating various risk disciplines, such as operational risk, financial risk, and compliance risk, organisations can gain a comprehensive view of risks and their interdependencies.
IRM promotes a holistic understanding of risks, enabling organisations to make well-informed decisions that consider the broader impact on multiple areas of the business. It encourages a shared language and consistent methodologies for risk assessment, allowing for more effective communication and coordination.
Furthermore, IRM encourages the alignment of risk management with strategic objectives. By integrating risk considerations into strategic planning processes, organisations can identify and address risks that could hinder the achievement of their goals. This proactive approach ensures that risk management becomes an integral part of decision-making at all levels of the organisation.
Continuous Improvement and Adaptation Risk management is not a one-time exercise but an ongoing process. As the business landscape evolves, new risks emerge, and existing risks change in nature. Therefore, organisations must continuously review and adapt their risk management strategies to remain effective.
Regular risk assessments and monitoring mechanisms help identify emerging risks and allow for timely adjustments to risk mitigation strategies. Additionally, organisations should foster a culture of learning and improvement, encouraging employees to report near-misses, share lessons learned, and propose enhancements to existing risk management practices.
In today’s volatile business environment, effective corporate risk management is essential for organisations to survive and thrive. By understanding the principles, methodologies, and best practices outlined in this BusinessRiskTV Guide, businesses can develop robust risk management strategies that protect their assets, reputation, and bottom line.
Remember, risk management is a proactive and integrated process that requires a risk-aware culture, structured methodologies, and the effective use of technology. By identifying and assessing risks, developing appropriate mitigation strategies, and continuously monitoring and adapting, organizations can navigate uncertainties with confidence and seize opportunities for growth.
Stay informed, stay vigilant, and make risk management a priority to ensure the long-term success of your organisation in an ever-changing business landscape.
Expert network helping business leaders manage business risks better on BusinessRiskTV.com
Leading experts in their industry or country come together to make business decision making easier. Discover the best business practices quicker. Exchange business risk management information. Ask how to overcome business barriers.
Governance risk and compliance expert network offering you tips help and support to manage business risks
Subscribe to BusinessRiskTV for free alerts and bulletins on upcoming webinars and risk expert panel questions and answers
Business experts share corporate risk management knowledge. Avoid procrastination and make better business decisions. Grow your business faster.
Network with our community of business experts to help protect your business and grow it faster with less uncertainty
Find risk management consultants you need for your business. Our business risk management experts can answer your questions provide advice and provide risk insight.
Our experts panel online events are designed to help your business grow faster. Access good business risk management advice on the risks in your country and industry. Develop and protect your business better. Find answers to questions about your own business risks. Ask the experts.
Do you need advice from an expert?
In the world of business, making the right decisions can be the difference between success and failure. Business owners must be able to weigh the potential risks and rewards of each decision before taking action. But with so many variables to consider, making good business decisions can be a daunting task. Fortunately, BusinessRiskTV.com is here to help. In this article, weāll explore the importance of good business decisions and how BusinessRiskTV.com can help you make them.
Why Good Business Decisions are Important
Making good business decisions is essential for the long-term success of any company. Here are a few reasons why:
Maximising profits: Good business decisions can help you maximise your profits by identifying opportunities to cut costs, increase revenue, and improve efficiency.
Mitigating risks: Every business decision involves some level of risk. Making good decisions can help you identify and mitigate potential risks, reducing the likelihood of financial losses.
Building trust: Making good decisions can help build trust with customers, employees, and investors. By demonstrating your ability to make sound decisions, you can inspire confidence in your stakeholders and build a positive reputation for your company.
Improving innovation: Good business decisions can lead to innovative ideas and solutions, helping your company stay ahead of the competition.
How BusinessRiskTV.com can Help
BusinessRiskTV.com is an online platform designed to help businesses manage risks and make informed decisions. Here are some of the ways BusinessRiskTV.com can help you make good business decisions:
Risk Management Tools: BusinessRiskTV.com provides a wide range of risk management tools to help you identify, assess, and mitigate potential risks. These tools can help you make informed decisions based on data-driven insights.
Expert Advice: BusinessRiskTV.com provides access to a network of experts in various industries. These experts can offer valuable insights and advice on how to make informed business decisions.
Industry Insights: BusinessRiskTV.com provides access to a wealth of industry insights and data. By staying up-to-date with the latest trends and developments in your industry, you can make informed decisions that give you a competitive edge.
Training and Education: BusinessRiskTV.com provides training and education resources to help you and your team improve your decision-making skills. By developing your ability to make informed decisions, you can improve the overall performance of your company.
Examples of Good Business Decisions
Letās take a look at some real-world examples of good business decisions:
Appleās Decision to Focus on Design: In the early 2000s, Apple made the decision to focus on design, creating products that were both aesthetically pleasing and functional. This decision helped Apple differentiate itself from competitors and build a loyal customer base.
Netflixās Decision to Move into Original Content: In 2013, Netflix made the decision to move into original content, producing shows like House of Cards and Orange is the New Black. This decision helped Netflix reduce its reliance on licensed content and establish itself as a major player in the entertainment industry.
Amazonās Decision to Invest in Technology: Amazon has consistently invested in technology, from its early days as an online bookseller to its current position as a leading e-commerce and cloud computing company. This decision has helped Amazon stay ahead of the competition and maintain its position as a market leader.
Coca-Colaās Decision to Expand into New Markets: Coca-Cola has a long history of expanding into new markets, from its early days in the United States to its current position as a global brand. This decision has helped Coca-Cola maintain its position as one of the worldās most recognisable brands.
Fordās Decision to Introduce the Model T: In 1908, Ford made the decision to introduce the Model T, a car that was affordable and easy to produce. This decision revolutionised the automobile industry, making cars accessible to the average person and transforming transportation as we know it.
These examples demonstrate the importance of making good business decisions and the impact they can have on a companyās success.
Making good business decisions is essential for the long-term success of any company. By identifying and mitigating potential risks, maximising profits, building trust, and improving innovation, good business decisions can help companies stay ahead of the competition and achieve their goals.
BusinessRiskTV.com is an online platform designed to help businesses manage risks and make informed decisions. By providing access to risk management tools, expert advice, industry insights, and training and education resources, BusinessRiskTV.com can help companies make informed decisions that drive their success.
So if you want to make good business decisions, turn to BusinessRiskTV.com. With its wealth of resources and expert guidance, you can make informed decisions that help your company achieve its goals and thrive in todayās competitive business landscape.
All types of risk management tips advice and support on BusinessRiskTV.com
Could you help business leaders and help yourself at the same time? You can with BusinessRiskTV. Join our panel of enterprise risk management experts. Network with your peers and risk management experts to boost your business performance. Pick up tips to overcome barriers to business growth.
Importance Of Risk Taking In Business
Subscribe to BusinessRiskTV for free alerts and bulletins to upcoming panel discussions and debates
Subscribe to UK Online for free for UK business and economy news views and reviews bulletins
Keep up to date with business risk management. Free news alerts and bulletins to your email inbox.
Promote and market your business on BusinessRiskTV for 12 months
Recommended UK business and economy articles and videos
What are business and economy bloggers saying today? What do you need to know today? Get help to manage your business better. Improve business performance.
Pick up tips advice and support to make better business decisions. Network with business leaders to overcome barriers to business quicker and cheaper. Do not reinvent the wheel!
Stop procrastinating and find ways to overcome barriers to your business success with BusinessRiskTV.com
What online networking groups do you have for risk management knowledge and skills development
Need to know more about benefits of risk management? Connect with local and international risk management experts. Protect your business better and grow it faster with BusinessRiskTV risk management online network and other specialist networking opportunities.
Connect with people locally and globally to develop your risk management knowledge. Pick up the latest risk management news opinions and business reviews for free.
Join us on Risk Management Online for free networking on YouTube enterprise risk management
Promote and market your business on BusinessRiskTV for 12 months
Put your products or services in front of new customers already interested in your type of business offering before your competitors do.
Link into your existing sales process direct from BusinessRiskTV or use our eCommerce solutions to increase your sales cash flow and profit
Increase the sources of your revenue streams more sustainably. Grow your business faster with BusinessRiskTV.
Access latest enterprise risk management insight and business intelligence
Help from country risk experts and industry risk experts. Solve your business problems faster. Boost performance. Protect business better. Grow faster.
Maximise return on your investment of time and money
Identify risk improvements necessary. Develop your skills and the risk management skills of workforce. Review where you are now. Receive recommendations for corporate risk improvements. Our risk management experts can help guide your business decisions.
Manage the issues facing your business better. Gain enterprise risk insight to understand threats and opportunities.