Woke Capitalism: A Critical Look
Woke capitalism refers to the trend of corporations publicly supporting progressive social and political causes. While some see this as positive social responsibility, others criticise it for various reasons. Here’s a breakdown of woke capitalism and arguments against it:
What it is:
- Companies take stances on social justice issues like racial equality, LGBTQ+ rights, or environmentalism.
- This can involve public statements, marketing campaigns, or donations to activist groups.
Reasons Why Some Find it Problematic:
- Inauthenticity: Critics argue companies might prioritise virtue signalling over genuine action, potentially neglecting labour practices or environmental impact within their own operations.
- Consumer Alienation: It can alienate consumers who disagree with the causes a company champions, potentially leading to boycotts.
- Distraction from Core Business: Focusing on social issues might distract companies from core competencies and delivering quality products or services.
- Government Overreach: Some argue corporations shouldn’t wade into political or social issues traditionally handled by governments.
- Increased Polarisation: Public company stances on social issues can further divide an already polarised society.
- Superficial Change: Critics argue it promotes performative activism that doesn’t address systemic problems.
- Employee Morale: Employees who disagree with a company’s social positions might experience lower morale or feel pressured to conform.
- Free Speech Concerns: Some argue companies expressing social views chills free speech in the marketplace.
- Increased Regulation: Governments might impose stricter regulations on businesses seen as wielding undue social or political influence.
- Mission Creep: Companies might get drawn into complex social issues beyond their expertise, leading to missteps.
- Investor Pushback: Investors focused solely on profits might object to companies taking actions not directly tied to financial gain.
- Greenwashing: Companies might use social stances to mask environmentally unfriendly practices (e.g., an oil company promoting LGBTQ+ rights).
It’s important to note:
- The validity of these arguments depends on the specific situation and a company’s execution.
- Some consumers might be drawn to companies that align with their values.
Woke capitalism is a complex issue with no easy answers. Understanding the potential drawbacks allows for a more informed discussion about its role in society.
Greenwashing was the last phase of the emergence of woke capitalism where businesses were overtly goody-2-shoes farcical shells of real business entities, then pretended to be good but weren’t really! Higher inflation, interest rates and borrowing costs for consumers, businesses and governments is bringing an end to even greenwashing phase as all 3 revert to survival mode including reinvestment in fossil fuels to lower energy costs, redundancies and severe cost cutting to try to achieve financial goals and financial business performance at expense of non financial goals like social responsibility, environmental protection and good corporate governance. The markets will want their pound of financial flesh and what the markets want they eventually get!
Risk management power in boardroom has peaked because it over-egged the pudding! Risk management lost its sensible capitalism focus of being financially sound first and foremost, in terms of ensuring good financial performance and gains first, and drifted off into woke projects that serve none of a businesses stakeholders well in the long run. The day of reckoning is coming fast but business leaders would be wise not to fling sensible holistic risk management practices with the bath water cause they will need them to know what is important in the fight to survive the rest of the 2020’s! As the Emperors clothes fall from our eyes the real world of business is about to make this realisation very painful for business leaders, consumers and governments and a large number of businesses will not be around for the next business expansion period. What are you doing to survive till then ? How will you ensure your business will be one of the survivors to prosper?
Get help to protect and grow your business
Subscribe for free business risk alerts and risk reviews
Read more business risk management articles